Western Gaming Has Fallen
Game showcases have been completely derailed.
Long gone are the days of E3, exciting keynotes packed with game reveals, surprise announcements and booth babes.
We now have State of Plays, Xbox Showcases, Nintendo Directs and whatever Hollywood-ripoff Geoff Keighley comes up with each year.
But this latest round of gaming showcases proved one thing:
Western Gaming Has Fallen
Here’s the evidence:
IMPORTANT: The Forge is the #1 source for everything that modern gaming is doing wrong, and the solutions studios must implement to turn the ship around.
If you want to dive deeper into how to predict whether a game will succeed or fail, and which game you should be building, consider becoming a paid subscriber.
You’ll get:
Market analysis on upcoming releases before the industry catches up.
Deep case studies on what makes players spend, stay and become your most powerful marketing force.
The audience no one is building for, and why they represent the most profitable opportunity in gaming right now.
Direct access to ask me questions directly and get my personal read on specific games or concepts.
A sneak peek into The Forge framework to build highly profitable games.
PlayStation Desperation
Wolverine opened PlayStation’s State of Play with nothing short of a bang.
Great visuals. A cinematic experience coupled with technical excellence that only Insomniac can provide. Blood and gore everywhere.
But marred by a strong case of deja vu… of ‘been there done that’, of spectacle over gameplay.
We already fought hordes of enemies in Batman: Arkham City.
We already jumped from one truck to another in Uncharted 2.
We already leaped onto a helicopter mid-flight, yanked its pilot and fed him into the rotor blades in X-Men Origins: Wolverine.
So far, Insomniac's Wolverine looks less like innovation and more like a greatest-hits compilation of things gaming did years ago. Debra Wilson and all..
We saw Marvel Tokon, another Rayman game, and an uninspiring remake of the original Tomb Raider no one really wanted, but that according to Alix Wilton-Regan it’s for ‘The Guys, The Girls, and The Gays’.
Needless to say… a Tomb Raider that looks more like Uncharted 2 than actual Tomb Raider.
Then we saw another ‘reboot’ in the form of Onimusha: Way of the Sword. There was Until Dawn 2, and a frankly promising ILL while the demographic that built PlayStation had to endure… these presenters.
And then PlayStation did the unthinkable in its desperation to be bold, edgy and modern.
It took the God of War franchise, and instead of giving players the next entry in Kratos’ saga, it showed… this…
It took a franchise defined by a brutal god dismantling mythologies with his bare hands and the Blades of Chaos… and transformed it into something that feels less like God of War and more like a walking simulator starring a middle-aged, suburban woman struggling through an identity crisis, accompanied by a talking cube that could just as easily be a washing machine.
Yes, that’s the state of the God of War franchise.
And that’s what defined the latest State of Play: a boring plethora of remakes, set pieces and one of the worst marketing decisions ever made in the history of gaming.
And this is only exhibit A of why Western gaming has fallen.
Of Games And Hollywood
It’s no secret that Geoff Keighley, a member of the IMAX royal family, wants to turn games into something that resembles Hollywood.
There’s no need for that, and there never will be a need for games to be treated like movies… with red carpets, cringe-inducing celebrities, and satin suits.
Games are the epitome of interactivity, art direction, and storytelling.
They’re MORE than movies.
Hollywood should be playing catch-up with the games industry, not the other way around.
And what was THE Western game that surprised everyone during Summer Game Fest 2026 while capturing the imagination of players worldwide?
Nothing. Crickets.
Yes, we’re excited for Lords of the Fallen II and The Blood of Dawnwalker, but we’ve known about them for years already.
And that was about all the Western scene had to show, aside from the ‘cozy’ indie games that only ‘professional games journalists’ seem to know about.
It’s sad. It’s depressing. But there’s one more thing that highlights the decline of Western gaming.
Xbox Xboxing
And now we come to Xbox.
The brand that is supposed to be saved by the industry’s anointed savior, Asha Sharma along with a first look at Gears of War E-Day.
And what did we get?
More Sea of Thieves.
More Minecraft Dungeons.
More Clockwork Revolution.
With only Magicians: The Devil’s Deal and Valor Mortis being the only interesting, new, creative offerings by Western developers.
As for Gears of War E-Day?
Yes, it looks and feels like Gears of War, but then you see the character designs and the way the game was presented, and you reach the same conclusion as this article’s title: Western gaming has fallen.
Let’s wrap things up.
Closing Thoughts
Notice the pattern.
PlayStation gave us remakes, cinematic set pieces, and a God of War spin-off that seems completely disconnected from the audience that built the franchise.
Summer Game Fest gave us Hollywood theatrics, celebrity appearances and almost no genuinely surprising Western titles.
Xbox gave us more sequels, more established brands, and more proof that the industry’s biggest publishers have become terrified of taking risks while focusing on representation checklists.
The West no longer knows who it’s building games for.
Instead of chasing players, it chases journalists.
Instead of creating icons, it creates committees.
Instead of delivering power fantasies, it delivers lectures.
Meanwhile, the most exciting projects in gaming increasingly come from studios that simply understand a basic truth:
Players want to have fun.
They want memorable characters.
They want beautiful worlds.
They want compelling gameplay.
And most importantly, they want games that respect the reason they became players.
The saddest part is that none of this was inevitable.
The industry simply forgot its audience.
And the moment an industry forgets the people who made it successful, its decline becomes only a matter of time.
Western gaming didn’t fall because players changed or grew older.
Western gaming fell because the industry did.
It fell in 2014
Excuse me . Are those presenters men? In dresses?